Experience waterfront living at its finest in this custom-built 5-bedroom, 3.5-bath home on Eagle Bay, boasting more than 200 feet of unobstructed Lake Erie frontage & breathtaking views. Reinstall the outdoor stairs for full access to the private beach & water below. This home features an extraordinary open-concept living space designed to maximize the waterfront setting, w/ soaring cathedral ceilings, a stunning wall of windows, & endless lake views.The chef’s kitchen is appointed with custom Amish-crafted cabinetry, quartz countertops, & overlooks the great room, dining area, & breakfast bar, ensuring the water remains the focal point. The great room’s wood-burning fireplace provides the perfect gathering space. Privately situated on the main level, the primary suite offers a peaceful retreat with a sitting area, walk-in closet, built-in wardrobe and full bath. A second first-floor bedroom w/ patio access & full bath provides flexibility for guests or multi-generational living. Upstairs, 3 additional bedrooms & a full bath accompany a covered balcony overlooking the grounds. Recent updates include a new roof (2025) & several windows (2026). With over 200′ of unobstructed Lake Erie views, this is a private waterfront sanctuary!
Property Details
Price:
$799,900
MLS #:
B1679089
Status:
Active
Beds:
5
Baths:
4
Type:
Single Family
Subtype:
SingleFamilyResidence
Neighborhood:
sheridan066400
Listed Date:
May 6, 2026
Finished Sq Ft:
4,192
Total Sq Ft:
4,192
Lot Size:
104,544 sqft / 2.40 acres (approx)
Year Built:
1991
See this Listing
Schools
School District:
Silver Creek
Interior
Appliances
Built In Range, Built In Oven, Double Oven, Dryer, Dishwasher, Electric Cooktop, Exhaust Fan, Gas Water Heater, Microwave, Refrigerator, Range Hood, Washer
Bathrooms
3 Full Bathrooms, 1 Half Bathroom
Cooling
Zoned
Fireplaces Total
1
Flooring
Carpet, Ceramic Tile, Hardwood, Tile, Varies
Heating
Gas, Zoned, Baseboard
Interior Features
Breakfast Bar, Ceiling Fans, Cathedral Ceilings, Separate Formal Dining Room, Entrance Foyer, Separate Formal Living Room, Great Room, Kitchen Island, Pantry, Pull Down Attic Stairs, Sliding Glass Doors, Window Treatments, Bedroom On Main Level, Bath In Primary Bedroom, Main Level Primary, Primary Suite
Laundry Features
Accessible Utilities Or Laundry, Main Level
Levels
Two
Main Level Bathrooms
3
Main Level Bedrooms
2
Exterior
Accessibility Features
Accessible Bedroom, Other
Architectural Style
Mediterranean, Two Story
Association Amenities
None
Attached Garage YN
1
Construction Materials
Brick, Stucco, Copper Plumbing
Exterior Features
Blacktop Driveway, Balcony, Concrete Driveway, Pool, Patio, Private Yard, See Remarks
Garage Spaces
2.5
Lot Features
Irregular Lot, Secluded
Other Structures
Other
Parking Features
Attached, Electricity, Garage, Other
Patio And Porch Features
Balcony, Covered, Open, Patio, Porch
Roof
Metal
Stories
2
View
Water
Waterfront Features
Lake, Other, See Remarks
Window Features
Drapes
Financial
Taxes
$10,792
Map
Community
- Address2386 Route 5 Sheridan NY
- CitySheridan
- CountyChautauqua
- Zip Code14136
Subdivisions in Sheridan
Market Summary
Current real estate data for Single Family in Sheridan as of Jul 18, 2026
10
Single Family Listed
38
Avg DOM
149
Avg $ / SqFt
$279,030
Avg List Price
Property Summary
- 2386 Route 5 Sheridan NY is a Single Family for sale in Sheridan, NY, 14136. It is listed for $799,900 and features 5 beds, 4 baths, and has approximately 4,192 square feet of living space, and was originally constructed in 1991. The current price per square foot is $191. The average price per square foot for Single Family listings in Sheridan is $149. The average listing price for Single Family in Sheridan is $279,030.
Similar Listings Nearby
Courtesy of HUNT Real Estate Corporation. Disclaimer: All data relating to real estate for sale on this page comes from the Broker Reciprocity (BR) of the New York State Alliance of MLSs. Detailed information about real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Michael Paduano include the name of the listing broker. Neither the listing company nor Michael Paduano shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. The Broker providing this data believes it to be correct, but advises interested parties to confirm any item before relying on it in a purchase decision. Copyright 2026. New York State Alliance of MLSs. All rights reserved. 2386 Route 5
Sheridan, NY