MP Home Team

5217 Tonawanda Creek Road
Pendleton, NY, 14120
$789,000
4 Beds
5 Baths
3,900 SqFt
1.3 Acres
Add
MLS #B1689974 image #0
Open House Jul 18, 2026
11:00 – 03:00
Welcome to 5217 Tonawanda Creek, a unique property in Pendleton Township and the highly regarded *Starpoint School District,* set behind a sweeping lawn, perennial gardens and a full-length covered front porch. *Park-like setting* Original structure dates to 1940, thoughtfully renovated in the 1980s to become a *bed and breakfast*. Current owner purchased the home in 2000 and has carefully maintained, updated, and enjoyed it as a *spacious single-family residence*. Its unique history is reflected throughout its generous proportions, flexible layout, abundant storage, and numerous gathering spaces. The impressive primary suite features hardwood floors, vaulted ceiling, sitting room, private bath, three closets, and a built-in cupboard. Three (3) other *en-suites* offer *remodeled* bathrooms with custom shower doors, creating comfort and privacy for family or guests. The *designer kitchen* and family room (2023) are made for everyday living and entertaining. Kitchen features center island, Sub Zero fridge, Wolf dual-fuel range, two Bosch dishwashers, two sinks, built-in pantry, china cabinets, abundant cabinetry, generous counter space, and access to rear deck. Adjoining family room boasts a new gas fireplace and built-in bookcase. Additional living areas include two stairways, gracious living room/dining room, office, and third-floor media room with handmade leaded-glass windows and separate HVAC system that could be a fifth bedroom. Outdoor living is also impressive. Enjoy warm-weather days from the covered front porch, rear deck, and private fenced *in-ground pool*. Take advantage of *riparian rights* and WNY waterways with a *personal dock* and kayak launch on the Erie Canal. Hundreds of thousands of dollars in improvements include high-efficiency furnace and AC with heat pump in 2024, *architectural-shingle roof in 2023*, driveway in 2023, backup whole-house *generator in 2022*, new pool pump in 2026, pool liner in 2022, remodeled bathrooms, new hot water tanks, new sump pump, new carpeting, and a beautifully finished laundry/mudroom with quartz countertop. Loaded with charm, character, storage, and thoughtful updates inside and out.

Property Details

Price:
$789,000
MLS #:
B1689974
Status:
Active
Beds:
4
Baths:
5
Type:
Single Family
Subtype:
SingleFamilyResidence
Neighborhood:
pendleton293200
Listed Date:
Jun 15, 2026
Finished Sq Ft:
3,900
Total Sq Ft:
3,900
Lot Size:
56,628 sqft / 1.30 acres (approx)
Year Built:
1980
Colonial,twostoryWaterfrontShedPendleton-293200Pendleton293200StarpointTonawanda CreekWater

Ask a Question

See this Listing

Send
  

Schools

School District:
Starpoint

Interior

Appliances
Dishwasher, Gas Water Heater
Bathrooms
5 Full Bathrooms
Cooling
Central Air
Fireplaces Total
2
Flooring
Carpet, Ceramic Tile, Hardwood, Luxury Vinyl, Varies
Heating
Gas, Forced Air
Interior Features
Breakfast Bar, Den, Separate Formal Dining Room, Eat In Kitchen, Separate Formal Living Room, Home Office, Kitchen Island, Kitchen Family Room Combo, Living Dining Room, Pantry, Solid Surface Counters, Window Treatments, Convertible Bedroom, Main Level Primary, Primary Suite
Laundry Features
Main Level
Levels
Two
Main Level Bathrooms
1
Main Level Bedrooms
1

Exterior

Architectural Style
Colonial, Two Story
Construction Materials
Aluminum Siding, Brick, Vinyl Siding, Copper Plumbing, Pex Plumbing
Exterior Features
Blacktop Driveway, Fence, Pool
Fencing
Partial
Lot Features
Irregular Lot, Residential Lot
Other Structures
Sheds, Storage
Parking Features
No Garage, Driveway
Patio And Porch Features
Covered, Porch
Roof
Architectural, Shingle
Stories
2
View
Water
Waterfront Features
Dock Access, Other, River Access, See Remarks, Stream
Window Features
Drapes

Financial

Taxes
$12,771

Map

Community

Market Summary

Current real estate data for Single Family in Pendleton as of Jul 16, 2026
21
Single Family Listed
63
Avg DOM
267
Avg $ / SqFt
$579,285
Avg List Price

Property Summary

    5217 Tonawanda Creek Road Pendleton NY is a Single Family for sale in Pendleton, NY, 14120. It is listed for $789,000 and features 4 beds, 5 baths, and has approximately 3,900 square feet of living space, and was originally constructed in 1980. The current price per square foot is $202. The average price per square foot for Single Family listings in Pendleton is $267. The average listing price for Single Family in Pendleton is $579,285.

Similar Listings Nearby

broker reciprocity
MLS# B1697594broker reciprocity
6690 Chesley Court
Clarence, NY

$985,000

4.2 miles away

broker reciprocity
MLS# B1632464broker reciprocity
8 Birch Lane
Amherst, NY

$949,900

4.9 miles away

broker reciprocity
MLS# B1674325broker reciprocity
166 Autumn Meadows
Amherst, NY

$923,800

2.0 miles away

broker reciprocity
MLS# B1676263broker reciprocity
7 Deer Run Court
Amherst, NY

$919,000

4.6 miles away

broker reciprocity
MLS# B1691282broker reciprocity
11 Stratford Court
Amherst, NY

$899,900

4.8 miles away

broker reciprocity
MLS# B1690335broker reciprocity
3400 Millersport Highway
Amherst, NY

$899,777

2.4 miles away

broker reciprocity
MLS# B1673759broker reciprocity
165 Autumn Meadows
Amherst, NY

$851,900

2.1 miles away

broker reciprocity
MLS# B1685743broker reciprocity
32 River Oak Lane
Amherst, NY

$839,900

2.3 miles away

broker reciprocity
MLS# B1682680broker reciprocity
17 River Oak
Amherst, NY

$835,900

2.3 miles away

broker reciprocity
MLS# B1660675broker reciprocity
809 Casey Road
Amherst, NY

$825,000

4.0 miles away

5217 Tonawanda Creek Road
Pendleton, NY