85 Hayden Street Buffalo NY 14210 MLS #B1681868

Prime South Buffalo Multi-Family Cash Flow Machine in Cazenovia ParkUnlock immediate strong cash flow with this turnkey 2-unit investment property at 85 Hayden St in the desirable Cazenovia Park neighborhood of South Buffalo. This 1920-built, 2,200 sq ft multi-family home features a spacious 3-bedroom lower unit and a 2-bedroom upper unit (total 5 beds, 2 baths) on a 30×110 ft lot. Recent updates include hardwood floors throughout, modernized systems (furnaces ~5 years old), and well-maintained interiors.

Proven Rental Income Current Total Rent: $2,310/month across both units — delivering exceptional performance well above Zillow’s Rent Zestimate of ~$1,335.
Annual Gross Income: $27,720.
Projected Gross Yield: Outstanding cash-on-cash returns in a market hungry for quality, affordable rentals from working families, local employees, and commuters.
Very low vacancy risk in this stable, family-oriented pocket with walkability to Tops Markets, restaurants, Cazenovia Park, and daily amenities.

Key Investor Advantages Attractive Acquisition: Zestimate ~$201K–$202K provides solid equity position with room for forced appreciation via light cosmetics.
Efficient Multi-Family Layout: Classic Buffalo double with separate utilities — perfect for owner-occupant investors or hands-off portfolio addition.
Location Strength: Quiet street in a competitive South Buffalo submarket — minutes to downtown Buffalo, major highways, and community anchors. Strong resale or 1031 exchange potential.
Tax Efficiency: Modest annual property taxes of approximately $1,732.

With verified rent of $2,310/month, 85 Hayden St stands out as a high-yield duplex delivering superior cash flow in a resilient Buffalo neighborhood. Ideal for investors seeking reliable income, tenant stability, and participation in Buffalo’s ongoing growth story. Opportunities like this in Cazenovia Park tend to move quickly.